When someone isn't a fit

I had to ask someone to leave once. He was not a bad housemate. He simply did not want what the house was, and neither of us knew that when we met for coffee.

I had to ask someone to leave once.

He was not a bad housemate. He paid rent, he was not unkind, he did nothing you could put on a list. He simply did not want what the house was, and neither of us knew that when we met for coffee.

It came out slowly. We would all be in the living room playing a board game, and he would be sitting near us with headphones on, playing video games on his computer and laughing at something none of us could hear. In the same room, and not with us.

We had a shared meal each week where one guy cooked and it rotated. On those nights he would make his own separate meal.

Then we started doing worship nights with just the guys in the house. He said it felt too intimate, that he did not know everyone well enough. He had lived there for months.

None of that is a character flaw. It is a mismatch, and it was mine as much as his. He thought he wanted community when we met. It turns out wanting community in theory and wanting it on a Tuesday night when you are tired are different things, and you often cannot tell which one someone has until they are living there.

What I would do differently

Be more specific up front about what participation means. Not "we value community" but "there is a house dinner every other Monday and everyone who lives here is at it." Name the worship nights. Name the shared meals.

Someone can opt out of a clear expectation. Nobody can opt out of a vague one.

Say it early and say it plainly

I let it go longer than I should have, partly because I kept hoping it would resolve and partly because the conversation was going to be uncomfortable.

It did not resolve. It hardened, and by the time I said something, everyone in the house had noticed and nobody had named it.

Say it the first time you notice the pattern, not the fifth.

What I said

Roughly this:

"Hey, it seems like what this house community is about isn't jiving with what you are looking for. We are pursuing spiritual community together, and I know you've voiced that the worship nights feel too intimate for you, and that you don't know the guys well enough after living here a few months. I think there may be a better fit for what you're looking for somewhere else."

He agreed with everything I said. He understood. It did not make it easy.

Notice what is not in there. No list of grievances, no mention of the headphones or the separate meals. Those were evidence, not the argument. The argument was simply that he wanted something different from what this house was, which he already knew.

And notice it does not end well, exactly. He agreed, it was still hard, and that is what these conversations are like. If you are waiting until you can have one that does not feel bad, you will wait past the point where it should have happened.

All guides